The Language & Thinking Program at Bard College Rotating Header Image

Cecelia Watson: “Points of Contention”

In late November of 1900, a spat broke out in Fall River, Massachusetts. “It was an unimportant, picayune sort of a personal quarrel,” the Chicago Tribune reported, “but it has had results of the greatest and most widespread importance.” The events were as follows: a resident of Fall River, Massachusetts walked into a hotel at 11:10 PM and ordered a drink. The hotel owner, aware that the man had been patronizing a rival hotel, decided to spite him by refusing him his drink, even though other patrons were being served. Thus denied, the man threatened to sue for discrimination; and on the following day he made good on his promise, retaining the services of a lawyer, who looked up the statute on liquor sales, which read:
“That no sale of spirituous or intoxicating liquor shall be made between the hours of 11 at night and 6 in the morning; nor during the Lord’s day, except that if the licensee is also licensed as an Innholder he may supply such liquor to guests who have resorted to his house for food and lodging.”

Based on this statute, the lawyer filed an injunction against the Fall River hotel owner, to prevent him from selling to anyone between 11 PM and 6 AM. A local judge granted the injunction, whereupon the hotel owner appealed the decision to the Massachusetts Supreme Court. Before the supreme court justices, the hotel owner’s attorney argued that the semicolon “was meant to be and should be construed, as a matter of fact, of being a comma.” In support of this claim, he noted that the law as originally passed in 1875 had contained a comma where the semicolon now intervened. The comma in the 1875 law was changed to a semicolon during “consolidation” of Massachusetts statutes in 1880. These consolidated statutes were presented to the legislature in 1881 and enacted with the semicolon in place. But because the 1875 parchment original of the law showed a comma, the whole debacle was an error of transcription, claimed the innkeeper’s attorney.

Find out who won, the comma or the semicolon, in faculty member Cecelia Watson’s forthcoming piece, “Points of Contention: Rethinking the Past, Present, and Future of Punctuation”>>

occupyantigone

The sound of a thousand rifles
fire at once
through heavy fog

a sudden burst of light
blinding like the scream of a child

voices, inaudible at first,
then unrecognizable,
resolve as sobbing wails

a figure enters
then two
then ten
then fifty

Woman, child, and man
They are Antigone
.

1: Mic Check!
ALL: Mic Check!
1: Mic Check!
ALL: Mic Check!
1: I am Antigone
ALL: I am Antigone
1: Tonight you will hear
ALL: Tonight you will hear
1: My Story
ALL: My Story


Collaborate>>

upcoming event: MONOLOGUES FOR ORPHEUS

A staged reading of a new play by Robert Kelly

MONOLOGUES FOR ORPHEUS

will be peformed by (program director) Thomas Bartscherer, (program faculty) Marjorie Folkman, Florian Becker, Lynn Behrendt, Mikhail Horowitz, and Paul La Farge

Friday, February 24th and Saturday, February 25th at 8 PM in Bard Hall.
Admission is free.

The play will be preceded by a musical induction featuring
Three Ancient Greek Songs for Tenor and Bassoon
by American composer Adrienne Elisha
performed by Peter Laki and David Adam Nagy.

US Consulate General: Language and Thinking at Al Quds University a success

From a press release from the Consulate General of the United States in Jerusalem:

Students and faculty from Al Quds University celebrated the completion of the “Language and Thinking” program on September 19 at a ceremony at the Red Crescent Society in Ramallah. The closing ceremony marked the conclusion of an innovative and rigorous academic program designed to teach first-year students at Al Quds University important skills in analytical thinking, writing, and reading. The pilot “Language and Thinking” program was funded through a U.S. Department of State Innovation Fund grant and was implemented by Al Quds University. The program, based on the Language and Thinking curriculum that has been in place at Bard College in New York for 30 years, provided an intensive 17-day introduction to the liberal arts and sciences for 50 freshmen from September 3-19, 2011.

Read the full press release>>

Language and Thinking Student Volunteers

“Could Language and Thinking host a dedicated hour each afternoon for students who wish to meet with students from other sections, or whoever shows up, to discuss what was studied in class sessions that day?” And, “When are we going to have a reunion party with all of the Language and Thinking faculty?” These were some of the questions and suggestions raised, among many others, at a meeting of Language and Thinking student volunteers last night. Program Director Thomas Bartscherer led a lively discussion with these first year students about the Program, including what they loved and what they would have liked to see done differently.

Cornell Creative Machines Lab: AI vs. AI

NYT: Computers in Classrooms

The chief technology officer of eBay sends his children to a nine-classroom school here. So do employees of Silicon Valley giants like Google, Apple, Yahoo and Hewlett-Packard.

But the school’s chief teaching tools are anything but high-tech: pens and paper, knitting needles and, occasionally, mud. Not a computer to be found. No screens at all. They are not allowed in the classroom, and the school even frowns on their use at home.

Schools nationwide have rushed to supply their classrooms with computers, and many policy makers say it is foolish to do otherwise. But the contrarian point of view can be found at the epicenter of the tech economy, where some parents and educators have a message: computers and schools don’t mix.

Read the full article, “A Silicon Valley School That Doesn’t Compute,” in the New York Times>>

2011 Fall Conference on Admissions

Prospective Bard students—juniors and seniors in high school—joined Language and Thinking Faculty today in Annandale-on-Hudson for sample Language and Thinking sessions during the 2011 Fall Conference on Admissions. Rebecca Chace, Anjuli Raza Kolb, Donna Ford Grover, and Jeffrey Champlin led the students in working with texts by Wallace Stevens, Raymond Patterson, Lydia Davis, Sophocles and Anne Carson.

Thomas Bartscherer: Switching Codes

Recently published: Switching Codes, edited by Program Director Thomas Bartscherer and Roderick Coover

From the University of Chicago Press: Half a century into the digital era, the profound impact of information technology on intellectual and cultural life is universally acknowledged but still poorly understood. The sheer complexity of the technology coupled with the rapid pace of change makes it increasingly difficult to establish common ground and to promote thoughtful discussion.

Responding to this challenge, Switching Codes brings together leading American and European scholars, scientists, and artists—including Charles Bernstein, Ian Foster, Bruno Latour, Alan Liu, and Richard Powers—to consider how the precipitous growth of digital information and its associated technologies are transforming the ways we think and act. Employing a wide range of forms, including essay, dialogue, short fiction, and game design, this book aims to model and foster discussion between IT specialists, who typically have scant training in the humanities or traditional arts, and scholars and artists, who often understand little about the technologies that are so radically transforming their fields. Switching Codes will be an indispensable volume for anyone seeking to understand the impact of digital technology on contemporary culture, including scientists, educators, policymakers, and artists, alike.

At a moment when culture’s digital makeover seems to have induced epistemological vertigo in many, Switching Codes offers a timely and well-targeted intervention. This book practices what it preaches, provoking cross-disciplinary dialogue and challenging the staid form of the usual essay collection, offering instead an engaging set of critical texts, poetry, fiction, games, and responses. Bartscherer, Coover, and their authors take up the challenges posed by the digital arts and humanities, mapping their new contexts, defining their analytic repertoire, and compelling a fresh set of insights. More than a portrait of our times, Switching Codes exemplifies the very logics that it explicates.
–William Uricchio, Massachusetts Institute of Technology

Find the link to play “Figment”, a game featured in Switching Codes, and buy the book>>

David McNeill’s 2010 Rostrum Lecture published in Inquiry

The lecture David McNeill gave to students during the 2010 Rostrum lecture series, on “Antigone’s Autonomy”, has been published in the academic journal Inquiry.

Vol. 54, No. 5, 411–441, October 2011
Antigone’s Autonomy
DAVID N. MCNEILL, University of Essex, UK

ABSTRACT: Sophocles’ Antigone contains the first recorded instance of the word αu’ τ ´oνoμoς, the source for our word “autonomous”. I argue that reflection upon
the human aspiration toward autonomy is central to that work. I begin by focusing on the difficulty readers of the play have determining whether Antigone’s actions in the play should be considered autonomous and then suggest that recognizing this difficulty is crucial to a proper understanding of the play. The very aspects of Antigone’s character that seem to militate against understanding her actions within the play as autonomous—her rejection of life, her intimacy with death and the way she seems defined by her incestuous heritage— serve to illustrate the inherently problematic character of a moral ideal that we can provisionally call Antigone’s autonomy. I show how the movement of the play can be understood in terms of Antigone’s progress from what Kant would characterize as a heteronomous representation of her irremissible duty to bury her dead brother, to a self-conception defined by a recognition and embrace of her autonomy understood as, in Kant’s words, “a respect for something entirely different from life”. Antigone’s autonomy is exemplified by her choice to be dead, the choice to bear the burden of responsibility to her own. This choice, I argue, must be understood as the choice of herself as defined by her obligation to her own. Sophocles’ Antigone suggests that the moral ideal Antigone represents is unlivable, but that this ideal is nonetheless essential to human moral aspiration.

Click here to see the video of the lecture and to find other 2010 Rostrum videos>>

Maika Pollack: Blinky Palermo: Original Gangster?

It’s worth asking why Palermo’s brand of indifferent, awkward objects looks so good to us today. The pieces from this show would look relevant in any contemporary art gallery on Orchard Street. He’s been influential to artists working now: Rirkrit Tiravanija invokes his name, Gareth James’s work echoes Palermo’s subtle architectural tracings, and his wobbly modernism is related to that of David Hammons and Franz West.

In a moment when America finds itself nostalgic for a powerful economic past and is increasingly unable to compete in a global economy, Palermo’s love of American style and his material meditations on the impossibility of living up to the task of being successfully American feel newly potent.

Read the full post from faculty member Maika Pollack in the New York Observer>>

NYT: Rostrum speaker Ben Shute, ” A New Generation of Farmers”

If our lawmakers decide that American farmers should hire only American workers, then we as a country have a lot more work to do than just enforcing rules against illegal labor. We need to set a national priority to encourage a new generation of young farmers, and we must adjust our system of agriculture to make farms into places where Americans want to work.

Read the full post from Benjamin Shute and further discussion on The New York Times website>>

Watch Benjamin Shute in a panel discussion with other Hudson Valley farmers during the 2011 Language and Thinking Program>>

The Essay Prize

From Faculty member Karen Lepri:

About The Essay Prize (www.essayprize.org):

“The Essay Prize,” according to the sponsoring organization’s website, “is given each year to the work that best exemplifies the art of essaying—of inquiry, rumination, discovery, and change. Open to projects in any medium or form—be it text, film, radio, performance, or other—the Essay Prize intentionally stretches the definition of “essaying” in order to celebrate work that is defined by what it *does*—the activity that it engages in—rather than what it *is*—its “nonfictional” verifiability.”

The site offers links to current nominees, which right now include a wonderful essay by Jenny Boully “On Being,” in which Boully writes through her own quest for identity as a Thai-American writer, and a truly powerful and useful (teaching-wise) video piece “Bed Intruder Song” by The Gregory Brothers that parodies the media’s propagation of racial stereotypes. Texts referred to via this site can be engaging for writers and teachers of essay-writing, in the first place as a way to reflect on what it means “to essay,” but even more so, as a source for audio/visual prompts that might be used to begin or to alter the direction of an essay.

The current prize winner is “New Normal?” by Radiolab’s Jad Abumrad and Robert Krulwich. My personal favorite among the current nominees is the video “Plastic Bag” by Ramin Bahrani, mainly because it works. I shared it with my mother who afterward said it finally, fully convinced her never to accept a plastic bag again. With all these examples, it’s interesting to ask, why do they work?

Visit The Essay Prize.org>>

Huff-po: If music be the food….

If music be the food of educational excellence, play on Maestro Botstein. Give me excess of Richard Strauss’s Die Liebe der Danae at Bard Summerscape 2011.

That strain again Maestro, it had a dying fall. It came o’er my ear like the sweet sound of newly arriving Bard freshmen eager to experience this spectacular operatic production (comedy, romance and drama set against Strauss’s brilliant orchestral score), whilst relishing other rich works of literature and honing their writing skills in this, their first fantastical college orientation.

Enough, no more of this brevity.

Read the full piece and interview with Bard President Leon Botstein from C. M. Rubin on the Huffington Post>>

Bard Prison Initiative Featured on PBS NewsHour

Watch the full episode. See more PBS NewsHour.

What college is tougher to get into than Harvard, Princeton or Yale? Bard College. Not the campus in Annandale-on-Hudson, N.Y., but the one behind bars in five Empire State prisons. The privately funded Bard Prison Initiative is putting convicts through a rigorous B.A. program that would challenge even the smartest Ivy Leaguers.

Watch the full episode. See more PBS NewsHour.